Over the past few days, overtaken by deadlines and pending projects, I’ve found myself chugging down quite a magnitude of energy drinks to fuel my midnight sprints. Hustlers, this isn’t unfamiliar territory, after all, the morning coffee is already a beloved comrade in our quest for the daily bread. But while I did manage to push through the dark and lonely tunnel of fatigue, it got me wondering: what exactly are these extra stimulants doing to my body? And in a broader sense, how do they stack up against something like alcohol, another commonly consumed, socially accepted substance? That curiosity led me down a rabbit hole of research, and what I found might surprise you.
So, are energy drinks worse than alcohol? Here’s what experts, and the internet for that matter, have to say.
What Makes it: Energy Drinks vs. Alcohol
Let’s start with the very basics: composition; what exactly makes these drinks?
Energy Drinks
Energy drinks are dominantly comprised of caffeine, anywhere from 40 mg to a whopping 250 mg per can. Add to that sugar (often over 30 grams), taurine, B-vitamins, herbal extras like ginseng and guarana, and you have yourself a high-powered concoction aimed at keeping you alert and amped. (My fantasy brain just imagined some medieval herbalist coming up with something of the sort for the workers, what a witch, she would be named!) On paper, energy drinks seem like liquid motivation. But the reality issss a little this and that.
For a brief insight, the drinks work by stimulating the central nervous system, tricking you into feeling more awake, more focused, maybe even unstoppable. But at what cost? High doses of caffeine can increase heart rate and blood pressure, trigger anxiety, mess with your sleep(tried and true), and even lead to heart arrhythmias in extreme cases.
Alcohol
Alcohol, or ethanol, on the other hand, is a depressant. This means that where the energy drink will boost activity, this one slows down brain activity and relaxes your central nervous system. It might feel like a good time in the short term, but it’s not exactly harmless.
Regular alcohol consumption has been proven to potentially damage almost every organ in the body. It raises your risk of liver disease, certain cancers, heart problems, and brain shrinkage(which made me rethink my weekend plans). And while the immediate effects include a buzz or euphoria, they’re usually followed by impaired judgment, dehydration, and — let’s be honest, those pounding hangovers are not very inviting.
Between Alcohol and Energy Drinks, Which Is More Harmful?
Now to the big question. If you’re looking to fuel a project all-nighter or wind down after a hectic week, which option is doing you more damage?
Cardiovascular Health
Energy drinks are notorious for causing spikes in heart rate and blood pressure. In some people, they’ve triggered strokes, especially when consumed in large amounts. Alcohol isn’t any better; over time, it can lead to heart failure, irregular rhythms (like atrial fibrillation), and high blood pressure.
But in all these, this is the ultimate difference: energy drinks typically hit hard and fast, while alcohol’s damage builds slowly and steadily, stealthily, and by the time you realize the effects, you are done for. Think of energy drinks as throwing your heart into overdrive, while alcohol quietly wears it down.
Mental & Emotional Impact
Caffeine can make you jittery, anxious, and restless, especially in high doses. If you have ever fueled up for an all-nighter, finished your work, and then tried to sleep, then you have probably dealt with feeling exhausted and tired, but not quite being able to sleep because the body is still stuck in overdrive. In fact, energy drinks are known for interfering with your sleep, which has a whole domino effect on mental health.
Alcohol, on the other hand, affects mood and decision-making. It lowers inhibitions and impairs memory(a great deal-breaker as I prefer perfect recollection of all my mischief), and prolonged use is tied to depression and dependency. If you’ve ever regretted a text (or five) sent under the influence, you know what I mean.
While still on the subject, check out Mental Health Rise Among Uganda’s Youth
Dependency & Addiction
Energy drinks can lead to caffeine dependence, and you start needing more to feel normal. You might get withdrawal headaches, mood swings, or fatigue if you skip your usual dose…
But alcohol’s dependency cycle usually takes it further. It involves physical addiction, withdrawal symptoms that can be life-threatening, and a high risk of abuse. The World Health Organization attributes 3 million deaths annually to alcohol. No energy drink can claim numbers like that.
Cancer & Organ Damage
Energy drinks haven’t been directly linked to cancer. Their risks revolve around heart strain, sugar overload, and mental health effects.
Alcohol, though, is an entirely different story. It’s classified as a Group 1 carcinogen, meaning there’s solid evidence it causes cancer. Even moderate drinking has been linked to increased risks of breast, liver, and colorectal cancers.
How About Mixing Energy Drinks and Alcohol
Now that’s where things get truly risky, combining both. And I get it, we humans are a truly daring species, but while that vodka Red Bull might sound like fun on a night out, it’s actually a minefield.
Caffeine masks the sedative effects of alcohol, making you feel more sober than you actually are. That means you’re more likely to binge drink, take risks, and misjudge your limits. You’re also dehydrating your body and stressing your heart in two opposite directions at the same time. The result? An increased risk of arrhythmias, blackouts, and even sudden cardiac events…a hyper overdrive in my own words
So… Which One’s Worse?
If we’re being clinical, alcohol is worse in terms of overall health impact, long-term damage, and risk of death. It’s more addictive, more toxic to organs, and directly linked to life-threatening diseases.
Energy drinks have been less threatening, but even then, chugging multiple cans a day, especially with little sleep and high stress, can still hurt your heart, mind, and metabolism. In high doses or when mixed with other substances, they’re dangerous too.
Though energy drinks are safe when consumed in low amounts, they can cause a variety of adverse health effects when consumed in excess.Excess caffeine from energy drinks can cause issues with the heart, kidneys, and blood sugar regulationThough most adults can safely consume small to moderate amounts of energy drinks, teens, children, and people with certain medical conditions should avoid them. – What Happens to Your Body When you Drink Energy Drinks, VeryWellHealth.com
In fact, one Reddit user summed it up well: “Caffeine messes with my sleep and anxiety. But alcohol messed with my life.”
In the end, personal moderation is how you get around it. I take my energy drinks and coffee pretty much once a day and still pass my health tests. A coffee or energy drink here and there won’t kill you, nor will the occasional drink. But overdoing either or mixing them will surely come with express consequences.
